COGG BBS

Hi!

Rias mentioned in Discord that he'd prefer to see suggestions here on the Board, so I decided to dump a few ideas I've been holding onto. Since one-handed swords only have two craftable options right now (rapier, cutlasses and shortswords), I've put some thought into what other options might be reasonable.

Obviously, falchions seem like the low-hanging fruit since they already exist in-game. With their hack damage, and lack of armor-chink ability, they fill an interesting niche. And I really just like their look.

Another option would be sabers. Probably similar or identical stats to rapiers (or maybe slightly more durable, slightly less chinking?).

I seem to remember that CLOK had khopeshes as well, though I'm not sure if they're still thematic here.

Anyway - I just think it'd be neat to expand the craftable availability of weapons, though I imagine it's pretty low on the priority list.

Huge fan of the craftable falchion suggestion. Would definitely include one in my warrior's arsenal.

I am stealing this following idea from CLOK, but I did love it, and I do believe it might have its uses here. It was great fun, imagining my character's stealthy girlfriend pull out a pair of dagger-like hairpins. I'd imagine they should serve similar functions to stilettos? Maybe be a little less effective because they're also intended for something else?

I've seen broadswords mentioned left and right, and I think it'd be great if some of our characters were finally able to use them, someday.

Frisbee wrote:I've seen broadswords mentioned left and right, and I think it'd be great if some of our characters were finally able to use them, someday.

As much as I dislike additions because a majority of people inevitably end up using them for a while because 'cool new thin' and it means that you have to wait and hope that people stop doing that if you actually have something planned for them (plate armor) and want to seem cool, I would jump on Broadswords the instant the came out. Those and Bearded Axes (though I believe Rias has said we aren't likely to get more axes).

Sorry for that runon sentence! Wheeew!

Okay, I think about this a lot. I am a total historical weapon nerd and this is something I desperately want to see. So, here's how I'd break it down, mechanically speaking:

One Handed Swords:
Single-edged sword, heavy curved: hack and slash (60/40)

• Falchion
  Cutlass
  Messer

Single-edged sword, light curved: slash only

• Scimitar
  Sabre
  Tulwar

Single-edged sword, cut and thrust: slash and pierce (70/30)

• Broadsword
  Backsword

Double-edged sword, cut and thrust: slash and pierce (50/50)

• Schiavona
  Spada
  Arming Sword (or just "sword")
  Bastard Sword (one-handed, -10% DF, extra reach)

Single-edged sword, recurved: hack only

• Kopis/Khopesh
  Yataghan

Sword, thrusting: pierce and slash (80/20)

• Rapier
  Smallsword

Daggers:
Long knives: slash and pierce (50/50)(extra DF & reach)

• Seax
  Gladius
  "Shortsword" (these are a vague fantasy item)
  Cinqueda
  Baselard

Short knives, single-edged: slash and pierce (70/30)

• Bowie
  Kitchen/Eating knife

Short knives, double-edged: pierce and slash (60/40)

• Dagger
  Dirk
  Main Gauche

Short knives, thrusting: pierce only (bonus against armor)

• Stiletto
  Misericord
  Rondel

Two-Handed Swords
Long Sword, double-edged: slash and pierce (50/50)

• Longsword
  Bastard sword (two-handed, -15% DF)

Long Sword, curved: slash only

• Kriegmesser

Great Sword, double-edged: hack and pierce (50/50)(+20% DF, extra reach, exhausting)

• Zweihander
  Spadone
  Montante
  Warsword

Great Sword, recurved: hack only (+20% DF, bonus against shields, exhausting)

• Rhompaia

I'm not sure of balance on other DF, reach, etc suggestions, but I think it conveys the point.

These are some great suggestions, thank you! I'll keep this post bookmarked for when I want to chase this particular butterfly and add some more weapon variety.

This kind of got me thinking about various "skins" for weapons for a wider diversity of things. What if ... hear me out here ... there was more of a mix and match system in play for various outcomes?

I.e. Take a longsword blade, a basket-hilt (instead of a crossguard) and the remaining pieces and you assemble a schiavona. A stiletto blade, knife handle, and a dagger crossguard nets you a misericorde. A stiletto blade and a knife handle gets a rondel. A dagger blade and a knife handle gets you a dirk or sgian dubh. Or a shortsword blade and a knife handle nets you a messer. cutlass blade and a knucklebow gets you a hanger. Etc, etc, etc.

System-wise, they're all just skins for the same type of weapon. A stiletto is a misericorde is a rondel, after all, so having each individual piece craftable for all the massive quantities of weapons from antiquity would be ... astronomical to code in. Not saying this method would be any easier but ... it would certainly be more interesting, in my opinion.